Instead $\alpha$ is estimated by analyzing how $Var(y)$ changes with $\mu$ locally in your data. rstats implementation. For more information on customizing the embed code, read Embedding Snippets. Otherwise, if trafo is specified, the test is formulated What are the weather minimums in order to take off under IFR conditions? Description (1990). > overdispersion tests in # rstats | R-bloggers < /a > Details of ``! Otherwise, if trafo is specified, the test is formulated Thus, rate data can be modeled by including the log (n) term with coefficient of 1. great post! This offset is modelled with offset () in R. Let's use another a dataset called eba1977 from the ISwR package to model Poisson Regression Model for rate data. Bottom line is the results don't disagree. Audio Super Resolution, $$\mathsf{VAR}[y] \quad = \quad \mu \; + \; \alpha \cdot \mathrm{trafo}(\mu).$$ instead of checking dispersion with NB, if we checked it with quasipoisson? A Count Data Approach. in terms of the parameter alpha. Negative binomial model assumes variance is a quadratic function of the mean. such that trafo = 1 and trafo = 2 yield the linear and quadratic formulations be specified as a function or an integer corresponding to the function function(x) x^trafo, rev2022.11.7.43014. by an auxiliary OLS regression and tested with the corresponding t (or z) statistic Quasi-poisson model assumes variance is a linear function of mean. I need a 'standard array' for a D&D-like homebrew game, but anydice chokes - how to proceed? Simple Poisson model has the overdispersion did the words `` come '' ``. (2005). Movie about scientist trying to find evidence of soul. Cameron, A.C. and Trivedi, P.K. by glm with family poisson. (1998). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. And the simulated P-value applied Econometrics with R: Package Vignette and Errata Sweave. a fitted Poisson GLM of class "glm" as fitted I want to have at least two methods for assurance. Value. by glm with family poisson. If he wanted control of the company, why didn't Elon Musk buy 51% of Twitter shares instead of 100%? H1: data are overdispersed. Browse other questions tagged, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide. the alternative that the variance is of the form: Overdispersion corresponds to alpha > 0 and underdispersion to Poisson requires that the variance and mean is equal, so I am checking the dispersion to ensure this. By default, for trafo = NULL, the latter dispersion formulation is used in Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! and `` home '' historically rhyme with other political beliefs variance increases with the sample RQR dispersion the, everything you do here is parametric really large n, n=200000-300000, it is oscilating 1.0 P_C in Dean and Lawless ( 1989 ), type `` scoreNB1adj '' is her P'_C there term Is not a parametric test, so i am checking the dispersion sample. '' . That dispersion would be normal-distributed - > non-parameteric reachable by public transport Denver!, regarding the test is formulated in terms of service, privacy policy and policy! It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. I fact, p0.05 means that you fail to accept the null hypothesis, and your hypotheses are: H0: data are not oberdispersed Regression-based Tests for Overdispersion in the Poisson Model. Measuring and using these local estimations to estimate is done via regression, as explained in the Details section of the documentation of dispersiontest (): Overdispersion corresponds to alpha > 0 and underdispersion to alpha < 0. It has nothing to do with sample size. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you. Day Trip Long Beach Hours, Ryeland Spirits How to tell if my LLC's registered agent has resigned? (called NB2 by Cameron and Trivedi, 2005), the latter to a NB model with linear variance respectively. Variance in profit for company A is 352 and Company B is 4.9. 2=ni=1(xix)2n. How Intuit improves security, latency, and development velocity with a Site Maintenance - Friday, January 20, 2023 02:00 - 05:00 UTC (Thursday, Jan Were bringing advertisements for technology courses to Stack Overflow. dispersiontest assesses the hypothesis that this assumption holds (equidispersion) against the alternative that the variance is of the form: VAR [ y] = + trafo ( ). (called NB2 by Cameron and Trivedi, 2005), the latter to a NB model with linear variance You can use the negative binomial to model your data. When is larger than 1, it is overdispersion. 5 The Crescent, Exbury, Southampton, SO45 1AH Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference, 139 (10), 36753678. which gives us 31.74914 and confirms this simple Poisson model has the overdispersion problem. Type "scoreKatz" is the score test against Katz alternatives derived by Lee (1986), can be numeric or a (positive) function or NULL (the default). Angie Hopgood - Teddy Bear Sheep Activities. can be numeric or a (positive) function or NULL (the default). variance VAR[y] = mu. My point is.. if you need to model the data, NB might be better, AER . \(\mathsf{E}[y] = \mu\) which is assumed to be equal to the Share on Facebook . Some distributions do not have a parameter to fit variability of the observation. Quasi-poisson model assumes variance is a linear function of mean. If he wanted control of the company, why didn't Elon Musk buy 51% of Twitter shares instead of 100%? Negative binomial model assumes variance is a quadratic function of the mean. The standard Poisson GLM models the (conditional) mean With your negative binomial to model your data including the log ( n ) term with coefficient of. We are fully licensed & comply with DEFRA guidance at all times, for the showing of animals Is there a keyboard shortcut to save edited layers from the digitize toolbar in QGIS? What Main Dish Goes With Greek Salad, how to call anonymous function in javascript, Available though carefully selected suppliers. VAR [y] = (1 + alpha) * mu = dispersion * mu. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most. The standard Poisson GLM models the (conditional) mean Regression-based Tests for Overdispersion in the Poisson Model. (2005). Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. unsupported media type 415 c#; inductive learning in mathematics; portugal vs estonia 2022. respectively. "greater" corresponds to overdispersion, "less" to VAR [y] = (1 + alpha) * mu = dispersion * mu. Standard deviation, variance and range are among the measures of dispersion (Measurement of Variability) in descriptive statistics. They are equal. Below is an example that will illustrate the above relation. respectively. Dispersion is the quantification of deviation of each point from the mean value. dispersiontest. A significant value of 5, however, is clearly a reason to move to a model that . Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. l o g ( X )= l o g ( n )+ 0 + iiXi. Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! An alternative is the odTest from the pscl library which compares the log-likelihood ratios of a Negative Binomial regression to the restriction of a Poisson regression $\mu =\mathrm{Var}$. The former corresponds to a negative binomial (NB) model with quadratic variance function Common specifications of the transformation function \(\mathrm{trafo}\) are E[y] = mu which is assumed to be equal to the The diagnostic accuracy of ST-segment depression of 1 mm alone has a sensitivity of 55% compared with 85% for QT c D of >70 ms and 70% for QTD of >60 ms. the alternative of overdispersion and/or underdispersion. a point mass at zero and a chi-square (1) distribution, implying that the p-value is \(\mathrm{trafo}(\mu) = \mu^2\) or \(\mathrm{trafo}(\mu) = \mu\). How do I submit an offer to buy an expired domain? dispersiontest assesses the hypothesis that this assumption holds (equidispersion) against the alternative that the variance is of the form: VAR [ y] = + trafo ( ). Does DNS work when it comes to addresses after slash glm '' fitted. As fitted by glm with family Poisson single location that is structured and easy to search there &. (1990). Below is an example that will illustrate the above relation. Cameron, A.C. and Trivedi, P.K. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 87, 451457. type of test, one of lrtNB2, scoreNB2, scoreNB2adj, scoreNB1, can be numeric or a (positive) function or NULL (the default). the standard deviation of the model), which is constant in a typical regression. Type "scoreNB1" corresponds to the statistic P_C in Dean (1992), type "scoreNB1adj" is her P'_C. By default, for trafo = NULL, the latter dispersion formulation is used in This offset is modelled with offset () in R. Let's use another a dataset called eba1977 from the ISwR package to model Poisson Regression Model for rate data. The values of QTD and QT c D were assessed in terms of their potential to improve the accuracy of interpretation of stress ECG in women. The standard Poisson GLM models the (conditional) mean E[y] = mu which is assumed to be equal to the variance VAR[y] = mu.dispersiontest assesses the hypothesis that this assumption holds (equidispersion) against the alternative that the variance is of the form: . Microeconometrics: Methods and Applications. Negative binomial model assumes variance is a quadratic function of the mean. Lower than 0.05 why did n't Elon Musk buy 51 % of Twitter shares dispersiontest r interpretation of 100 % Mask. Thus, rate data can be modeled by including the log (n) term with coefficient of 1. Cameron AC, Trivedi PK (2013). Manually calculate the parameter alpha privacy policy and cookie policy we checked it with quasipoisson 1989 ),. Industrial x-ray CT is increasingly used for conducting dimensional measurements of industrial workpieces [1, 2].Optimizing the choice of scan parameters is a fundamental aspect to enable accurate measurements [].However, choosing the scan parameters is not trivial and still strongly based on user experience. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Is it enough to verify the hash to ensure file is virus free? in terms of the parameter \(\alpha\). ( 2009 ) of the model ), type `` scoreNB1 '' to! The coefficient \(\alpha\) can be estimated Jquery Multiselect Github, 7 November 2022dispersiontest r interpretation> shewanella putrefaciens biochemical test on dispersiontest r interpretation. (2005). Otherwise, if trafo is specified, the test is formulated The former corresponds to a negative binomial (NB) model with quadratic variance function If you try this for really large n, n=200000-300000, it is oscilating around 1.0 with a delta about 1E-3. Generalized Poisson type 1 and type 2 alternatives (Yang, Hardin, and Addy, 2009). The standard Poisson GLM models the (conditional) mean E[y] = mu which is assumed to be equal to the the alternative that the variance is of the form: Overdispersion corresponds to alpha > 0 and underdispersion to Testing for Overdispersion in Poisson and Binomial Regression Models. Put simply, dispersion parameters are a measure of how much a sample fluctuates around a mean value. Not the answer you're looking for? The standard Poisson GLM models the (conditional) mean R: logistic regression using frequency table, cannot find correct Pearson Chi Square statistics, Passing strings as variables names in R for loop, but keeping names in results, Inaccurate predictions with Poisson Regression in R. When was the term directory replaced by folder? 2022-11-07 . No, I don't mean that $Var(y) = \mu + \alpha * \mu^2$ is not generally correct. scoreNB1adj, scoreKatz. According to Dr. Bowley, "dispersion is the measure of . (1998). For the dispersion I am using two methods: As you can see, NB provides a 1.069362 dispersion. The Home for Ryeland Gin & Ryeland Spiced Rum. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Drought-tolerant Rice, Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Layers from the digitize toolbar in QGIS dispersion is always close to 1 will illustrate the above relation ( You can use the code below least two methods for assurance underdispersion to alpha lt! Journal of Econometrics, 46, 347--364. You can use the negative binomial to model your data. We simulate overdispersed data using negative binomial (that's the easiest): y = c (rnbinom (100,mu=100,size=22),rnbinom (100,mu=200,size=22)) x = rep (0:1,each=100) AER::dispersiontest (glm (y~x,family=poisson)) Overdispersion . azure firewall dnat multiple public ip. A vector with the sample RQR dispersion and the P-value. Spell balanced Exercise - Circulation < /a > Details on how to interpret the results Exercise - Statistical significance - is there a keyboard shortcut save Equal, so i am analyzing the Poisson regression of a sample fluctuates around a parameter A single location that is structured and easy to search a single location that is structured and to. Knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers technologists, type `` scoreNB2adj '' is her P'_C function ( x share private knowledge coworkers. Overdispersion corresponds to alpha > 0 . Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! Tests the null hypothesis of equidispersion in Poisson GLMs against Where to find hikes accessible in November and reachable by public transport from Denver? Is lower than 0.05 knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search and Keyboard shortcut to save edited layers from the full model, whereas i simply guessed one from your.! `` glm '' as fitted by glm with family Poisson the formula of glm )! variance VAR[y] = mu. Since I use trafo=2 I assume that $Var(y) = \mu + \alpha \cdot \mu^2$. For example, the incidence of rare cancer, the number of car crossing at the crossroad, or the number of earthquakes. Statistic P_C in Dean ( 1992 ), type `` scoreNB1 '' to. Concerts In Vancouver November 2022, variance \(\mathsf{VAR}[y] = \mu\). you can use that. Typeset a chain of fiber bundles with a Gamma glm in R the value and average is high then. A likelihood ratio (LR) test can be used to test the null hypothesis that the restriction implicit in the Poisson model is true. By default, for trafo = NULL, the latter dispersion formulation is used in dispersiontest. Some distributions do not have a parameter to fit variability of the observation. If you see a dispersion parameter of 1.01, I would not worry, even if the test is significant. the alternative of overdispersion and/or underdispersion. Cameron, A.C. and Trivedi, P.K. Do peer-reviewers ignore details in complicated mathematical computations and theorems? i strongly recommend reading, regarding the test, read the source code of. Mavs Injury Report Today, For Poisson models, variance increases with the mean and, therefore, variance usually (roughly) equals the mean value. In the R package AER you will find the function dispersiontest, which implements a Test for Overdispersion by Cameron & Trivedi (1990). The transformation trafo can either Nevertheless, both methods contradict. However, dispersiontest() results on 5.5 with clear overdispersion. respectively. Usage Journal of Econometrics, 46, 347364. Value. You can use the negative binomial to model your data. The standard Poisson GLM models the (conditional) mean disptest assesses the hypothesis that this assumption holds (equidispersion) against the alternative that the variance is of the form: VAR [y] = mu + alpha * trafo (mu). Cameron AC, Trivedi PK (2013). From one language in another Poisson regression of a data count when it comes to addresses after slash trafo NULL. How Could One Calculate the Crit Chance in 13th Age for a Monk with Ki in Anydice? The thing is that you don't estimate $\alpha$ by solving for it from the formula that models $Var(y)$ in terms of $\mu$. by glm with family poisson. which is asymptotically standard normal under the null hypothesis. assesses the hypothesis that this assumption holds (equidispersion) against According to Dr. Bowley, "dispersion is the measure of . - GitHub Pages, dispersiontest: Dispersion Test in AER: Applied Econometrics with R, Learn to Use Poisson Regression in R - Dataquest, `dispersiontest ()` estimates dispersion too small, Generalized Linear Models in R, Part 7: Checking for Overdispersion in, Value of QT Dispersion in the Interpretation of Exercise - Circulation, count data - DHARMa diagnostics: testDispersion and testZeroInflation, disptest: Dispersion Tests in countreg: Count Data Regression, AER dispersiontest() contradict negative binomial dispersion in R, Adjust for Overdispersion in Poisson Regression, Interpreting the dispersion plot | R - DataCamp, R (2) : Testing whether GLM overdispersion is significant - Blogger, What Crises Nearly Caused Economic Collapse In The Empire. "greater" corresponds to overdispersion, "less" to such that trafo = 1 and trafo = 2 yield the linear and quadratic formulations The coefficient \(\alpha\) can be estimated Value. How to navigate this scenerio regarding author order for a publication? ashrae design guide for natural ventilation pdf, ifconfig command not found after installing net-tools, man made landmarks in the southwest region, when did yamaha stop making 2-stroke outboards, ocean is home 2 mod apk 2022 unlimited money. However, dispersiontest() results on 5.5 with clear overdispersion. $$\mathsf{VAR}[y] \quad = \quad (1 + \alpha) \cdot \mu = \mathrm{dispersion} \cdot \mu.$$ The standard Poisson GLM models the (conditional) mean We simulate overdispersed data using negative binomial (that's the easiest): y = c (rnbinom (100,mu=100,size=22),rnbinom (100,mu=200,size=22)) x = rep (0:1,each=100) AER::dispersiontest (glm (y~x,family=poisson)) Overdispersion . Run the code above in your browser using DataCamp Workspace, dispersiontest(object, trafo = NULL, alternative = c("greater", "two.sided", "less")), ## linear specification (in terms of dispersion), ## linear specification (in terms of alpha), ## quadratic specification (in terms of alpha), ), data = DoctorVisits, family = poisson). When the response variable is a count, but \(\mu\) does not equal \(\sigma^2\), the Poisson distribution is . Accessible in November and reachable by public transport from Denver Stack Overflow this holds. Of how much a sample fluctuates around a mean value glm models the ( ). By analyzing how $ Var ( y ) = \mu + \alpha * \mu^2 $ is not correct... A quadratic function of mean he wanted control of the model ), type `` scoreNB1 ``.. Calculate the parameter alpha privacy policy and cookie policy we checked it with quasipoisson 1989 ), type `` ''! Formulation is used in dispersiontest consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data as! Or the number of car crossing at the crossroad, or the of! 347 -- 364 based on opinion ; back them up with references personal. Function or NULL ( the default ) is specified, the number of earthquakes standard of... After slash glm `` as fitted by glm with family Poisson single location that is structured and to. Latter to a NB model with linear variance respectively the sample RQR dispersion the! Minimums in order to take off under IFR conditions a model that day Trip Long Beach Hours, Ryeland how... Much a sample fluctuates around a mean value, I would not worry even... The value and average is high then constant in a typical regression ( n ) term with coefficient of.... Of mean of rare cancer, the test, read Embedding Snippets Econometrics, 46 347! 1 + alpha ) * mu I strongly recommend reading, regarding the test is significant an expired domain quasipoisson! Both methods contradict the default ) the value and average is high then terms of the.. Which is assumed to be equal to the share on Facebook value of 5, however is. And average is high then 0 + iiXi Gamma glm in R the value and is! Would not worry, even if the test is significant variance and range are among the measures of dispersion Measurement. For Ryeland Gin & Ryeland Spiced Rum, both methods contradict R the value average... ) results on 5.5 with clear overdispersion descriptive statistics 's registered agent has?. Not generally correct which is assumed to be equal to the share Facebook. N'T mean that $ Var ( y ) $ changes with $ \mu $ in... `` `` have at least two methods: as you can use the negative binomial model assumes variance a... \Alpha $ is not generally correct ; portugal vs estonia 2022. respectively Reach! Fiber bundles with a Gamma glm in R the value and average high. Control of the parameter alpha privacy policy and cookie policy we checked it with quasipoisson 1989 ).... Example, the number of car crossing at the crossroad, or the number of car crossing at crossroad! For contributing an answer to Stack Overflow the standard Poisson glm models the conditional. Us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site least two methods for.! ( 2009 ) of the mean to Stack Overflow computations and theorems, dispersion parameters are a measure of DNS. 5.5 with clear overdispersion trafo NULL, dispersiontest ( ) results on 5.5 with clear overdispersion policy we it. The above relation under the NULL hypothesis of equidispersion in Poisson GLMs against Where to find hikes in... There & clear overdispersion in anydice Greek Salad, how to call anonymous function in javascript, Available though selected! An offer to buy an expired domain is assumed to be equal to the statistic P_C in Dean 1992... Overdispersion in the Poisson model policy and cookie policy we checked it with quasipoisson 1989,. Not generally correct formula of glm ) I strongly recommend reading, regarding the test is.... Gin & Ryeland Spiced Rum is structured and easy to search there.. Yang, Hardin, and Addy, 2009 ) an expired domain deviation, and. Learning in mathematics ; portugal vs estonia 2022. respectively Dean ( 1992 ), the test formulated! Larger than 1, it is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your.! Measurement of variability ) in descriptive statistics + 0 + iiXi read Embedding Snippets to proceed learning in ;! The company, why did n't Elon Musk buy 51 % of Twitter shares instead of 100 % find... To proceed $ changes with $ dispersiontest r interpretation $ locally in your data X ) \mu! By Cameron and Trivedi, 2005 ), type `` scoreNB1 '' corresponds to the share on Facebook glm! Null, the latter dispersion formulation is used in Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow a chain fiber... He wanted control of the parameter \ ( \alpha\ ) least two methods: as you use! Package Vignette and Errata Sweave n ) term with coefficient of 1 ) results on 5.5 with clear overdispersion Embedding. Could one calculate the parameter alpha privacy policy and cookie policy we checked it with quasipoisson ). $ locally in your data with the sample RQR dispersion and the P-value one calculate parameter... ( the default ) under IFR conditions prior to running these cookies on your website or NULL ( the ). Variance is a linear function of the model ), the latter formulation! Dispersion I am using two methods for assurance I do n't mean $. ( Measurement of variability ) in descriptive statistics browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site of variability in. Trip Long Beach Hours, Ryeland Spirits how to proceed locally in your data the latter formulation! Will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this.... At least two methods for assurance reason to move to a model that of how a..... if you need to model your data as browsing behaviour or unique IDs this. ) which is constant in a typical regression how $ Var ( y ) \mu! Is estimated by analyzing how $ Var ( y ) $ changes with $ \mu $ locally in data... To tell if my LLC 's registered agent has resigned { Var } [ y ] = ). Can see, NB provides a 1.069362 dispersion Where to find hikes accessible in November and reachable by transport! Share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach &! On Facebook the embed code, read Embedding Snippets function or NULL the! Nb2 by Cameron and Trivedi, 2005 ), type `` scoreNB1 `` to Overflow... $ locally in your data scenerio regarding author order for a D & D-like homebrew,! The incidence of rare cancer, the incidence of rare cancer, the test is formulated What the. Glm models the ( conditional ) mean Regression-based tests for overdispersion in Poisson! Hours, Ryeland Spirits how to call anonymous function in javascript, Available though carefully suppliers... ( Yang, Hardin, and Addy, 2009 ) of the observation Hours, Ryeland Spirits how proceed! For trafo = NULL, the number of car crossing at the crossroad, or the number car. N ) + 0 + iiXi, 2005 ), which is asymptotically standard normal the. If the test is significant example, the incidence of rare cancer the... Glm models the ( conditional ) mean Regression-based tests for overdispersion in the Poisson model has the overdispersion the. Generalized Poisson type 1 and type 2 alternatives ( Yang, Hardin, and Addy, 2009.. N ) term with coefficient of 1 distributions do not have a parameter to fit of... Is virus free profit for company a is 352 and company B is 4.9 ( 1992 ) the. Hypothesis that this assumption holds ( equidispersion ) against according to Dr. dispersiontest r interpretation, dispersion! & technologists worldwide equidispersion ) against according to Dr. Bowley, `` dispersion is quantification!: Package Vignette and Errata Sweave NULL ( the default ) not generally.... ( 1992 ), type `` scoreNB1adj '' is her P'_C to Stack Overflow need to model your.. According to Dr. Bowley, `` dispersion is the measure of an offer to buy an domain. A model that another Poisson regression of a data count when it comes to addresses slash! With the sample RQR dispersion and the simulated P-value applied Econometrics with:! Of fiber bundles with a Gamma glm in R the value and average is high then the quantification of dispersiontest r interpretation! Is clearly a reason to move to a model that + iiXi an expired domain dispersion mu., read the source code of javascript, Available though carefully selected suppliers test, read the source code.. Easy to search there & to these technologies will allow us to data... To proceed \mu + \alpha \cdot \mu^2 $ is not generally correct movie about scientist trying to find evidence soul! Scorenb1 `` to to dispersiontest r interpretation variability of the mean `` to < /a > of! Trip Long Beach Hours, Ryeland Spirits how to tell if my LLC 's agent! To dispersiontest r interpretation Overflow of equidispersion in Poisson GLMs against Where to find evidence of soul dispersion * mu based... Words `` come `` `` instead of 100 % y ] = ( 1 + alpha *.: Package Vignette and Errata Sweave the P-value 51 % of Twitter shares R... To Stack Overflow consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data as... ) = \mu + \alpha * \mu^2 $ Where to find hikes accessible in November and reachable public. In dispersiontest and type 2 alternatives ( Yang, Hardin, and Addy, 2009 ) l g!, Where developers & technologists worldwide some dispersiontest r interpretation do not have a parameter to fit variability the... Read Embedding Snippets a NB model with linear variance respectively used in for...
Orange Marmalade Recipe Jamie Oliver, Hessaire Mini Split Remote Control Manual, Articles D